What is Reader Response Criticism And Is It Valid?
Reader-response criticism is a school of literary theory that locates the meaning of a text in the reader's experience of it rather than in the author's intention or in the text alone. It took shape in the 1960s and 1970s, chiefly in the United States and Germany, and its best-known names are Louise Rosenblatt, Wolfgang Iser, and Stanley Fish. In what follows, I will define it, introduce its key figures and types, show how it differs from New Criticism, and explain why it fails as a method for reading the Bible.
Reader Response Criticism is a literary theory focusing on the reader's interpretation and response to a text. It suggests that the meaning of a text is not fixed and objective but rather subjective and dependent on the reader's experiences, beliefs, and cultural background. The reader plays an active role in creating meaning from a text, and their interpretation is just as important as the author's intention. It encourages readers to analyze their own responses to a text and examine how their personal biases and perspectives affect their understanding of it. It emerged in the latter half of the 20th century with roots in the work of Louise Rosenblatt and Stanley Fish.
The theory posits that a text is not a fixed entity with a single meaning but rather a dynamic creation that takes on new meanings with each reading. According to this approach, the meaning of a text is not solely determined by the author's intention but is also shaped by the reader's interpretation. The reader enjoys an active role not in identifying meaning but in its creation. It provides a framework for analyzing the reader's response to a text. Readers are encouraged to examine their own biases and perspectives and to consider how their personal experiences affect their interpretation of a text. This approach requires readers to engage with a text on a personal level and to consider how their unique position in the world shapes their response to it. By doing so, readers can gain a deeper understanding of the text and appreciate how it speaks to their own experiences and beliefs.
Who are the key figures in reader-response criticism?
Reader-response criticism is a family of related theories, and its proponents do not always agree with one another. Five names are especially significant.
Louise Rosenblatt is the forerunner. In Literature as Exploration (1938) and later The Reader, the Text, the Poem (1978), she argued that reading is a "transaction" between a reader and a text, borrowing the term from John Dewey. For Rosenblatt, the poem exists in that transaction.
Wolfgang Iser, working in Germany, gave the movement two of its most-used terms. The "implied reader" is the reader a given work requires, and the "gaps" are the places where the text leaves something unsaid and the reader must fill it in. His major work is Der Akt des Lesens (1976), translated as The Act of Reading. Hans Robert Jauss is the other important German name.
Stanley Fish began, in Surprised by Sin (1967), by studying what Paradise Lost does to its reader line by line. He later moved further, arguing that readers interpret as members of "interpretive communities" that supply their strategies for reading. His essays on that idea are collected in Is There a Text in This Class?
Norman Holland and David Bleich took the approach in a psychological and subjective direction, looking to the individual reader's identity, motives, and written responses as the place where meaning is found.
What are the types of reader-response criticism?
Lois Tyson sorts the field into five approaches, while warning that the lines between them blur. First, the transactional approach (Rosenblatt, Iser) holds that meaning arises from a transaction between what the text supplies and what the reader brings. Second, affective stylistics (early Fish) treats the text as an experience in time, as it is read. Third, the subjective approach (Bleich) finds meaning in readers' own responses, compared with one another. Next, the psychological approach (Holland) holds that the reader's motives and identity shape the reading. Lastly, the social approach (later Fish) holds that interpretation is produced within an interpretive community. What unites all five is the conviction that the reader participates in producing a text's meaning.
Reader-response criticism vs. New Criticism
It is important to note what reader-response criticism stands opposed to. New Criticism held that only what is within a text is part of its meaning; neither the author's intention nor the reader's psychology was admitted into the discussion. In 1949, W. K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley named the "affective fallacy": the error of judging a text by its emotional effects on a reader. Reader-response criticism turns that around. What New Criticism called a fallacy, reader-response critics treat as the starting point. In other words, New Criticism looks at the text, and reader-response criticism looks at what happens in the reader.
What is the reader-response lens?
When a literature teacher asks students to read "through a reader-response lens," the assignment is to attend to their own experience of the text: what they expected, where they were surprised, what they filled in, and how their background shaped all of it. As a classroom exercise, that has some value. Students should notice what they bring to a text. The trouble comes when the lens stops being an exercise and becomes a theory of meaning.
An example from Philippians 4:13
Take one of the most quoted verses in the New Testament: "I can do all things through him who strengthens me" (Phil 4:13, ESV). An athlete reads it before a game and hears a promise of victory. A reader-response approach has no ground on which to call that reading wrong; it is what the verse means for that reader, in that community. But Paul supplies the context two verses earlier:
Not that I am speaking of being in need, for I have learned, in whatever situation I am, to be content. I know how to be brought low, and I know how to abound. In any and every circumstance, I have learned the secret of facing plenty and hunger, abundance and need. I can do all things through him who strengthens me.
(Philippians 4:11–13, ESV)
The "all things" includes being brought low and going hungry. Paul is talking about contentment in Christ whether he wins or loses, which is nearly the opposite of the athlete's reading. The text has a meaning, and the reader can get it right or wrong.
What spurned this brief introduction to Reader Response Criticism was a quote that I came across a quote from Joel Green,
For many postmoderns, on the other hand, truth does not exist as an abstract reality apart from human knowing. Thus, for students of the Bible, meaning is not simply a property of the text that the reader must discover or excavate but is somehow the product of the interaction of readers with texts.
Positively, this criticism imbibes much of postmodernity's overshadowing of modernity's Biblical interpretation methods, such as form or source criticism. It is a useful critique against methods that simply did not provide meaningful ways of interacting with the Biblical text by showing that postmodern scholarship rightly called modern scholarship into question and found it not worth adapting. Negatively, it contains some peculiar statements that seem to undermine its own position.
For starters, it does not appear to consider the existence of other modes of truth outside of literary categories. This can be seen by the tree that falls in the wilderness. Before the tree is allowed the chance to fall and make a sound, which is done even if no one is around to hear it, the tree exists in the forest. The stubbornness of the tree's existence is seen in the fact that it exists whether I know about that tree or not. What I have just said also carries with it another layer of disagreement with Green's assessment. The very statement itself presents a truth that also exists whether the reader knew about it in the first place or not. Both the concept, the tree's existence, and the assertion about the tree's existence contain truth regardless of its knowability.
To complicate matters even further, the fact that Green's statement exists in and of itself further confirms how suspect his assertion is. He seems to present an idea in absolute terminology that he would logically think is true; otherwise, why would he have made the assertion in the first place? Green allowed for truth claims to exist independent of the reader's knowability to provide the meaning and truth of it. His statement suggests a category for truth and meaning, which is irrespective of the reader's participation.
The Bible cannot be placed in a category outside of modern texts where its meaning and truth cannot exist apart from the reader's contribution simply because it is an ancient text or it contains religious claims or religiously motivated ideologies. Much like the tree's existence cannot depend on how close I am to it or what type of tree it is. Postmodern interpreters would need to concede this point, or else it would be equally problematic for them. If the truth depended on proximity and genre, then a postmodern exegete's claims could not depend on the interaction between authorial intention and reader participation. There would be something inherently true about the text, controlling its interpretation.
The Bible contains timeless truths preserved throughout millennia. Its messages are clear and can be understood by any interpreter willing to understand its intended message. The Protestant Reformation did much to place the Scriptures in the hands of the reader but sought to preserve the message. The preservation of the message was extremely important to them, as it has been and continues to be for believers throughout all generations. The idea the reader is needed or even has the ability to participate in the generation of the text's meaning is unfounded. The reader seems to be less generating meaning and more making up meaning in order to suit their social contexts and worldviews. Participating in meaning may initially seem attractive as one can justify their views from a monumentally important text. What happens instead is that the life-changing, life-saving message of the Scriptures is lost. Historical criticism did much to generate widely divergent interpretations where the reader saw themselves in the Scriptures. Post-modern criticism, while rightly rejecting much of modern criticism's faulty methods, did much to adopt the same approach where the reader finds what they want to find in the Scriptures and that being themselves.
Is reader-response criticism valid for reading the Bible?
It should be conceded that reader-response critics are correct that every reader brings presuppositions to the text, and a good interpreter will be honest about his own. However, it is one thing to say that readers bring something to the text; it is an entirely different thing to say that readers create the text's meaning.
Reader-response criticism also undermines itself. If texts do not inherently have meaning, then how are we to know what Fish intended to say in his writings on reader-response criticism? Is it not possible that a reader could read Fish and conclude that he was an author-oriented critic? Fish expects to be understood. For the sake of consistency, the same must be true of the authors of Scripture. The theory lacks any meaningful criteria that would let a reader tell a faithful reading from an unfaithful one, since on its terms the text has no meaning of its own to be faithful to.
Scripture speaks to the question directly. Peter tells us that "no prophecy of Scripture comes from someone's own interpretation. For no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit" (2 Pet 1:20–21, ESV). When Ezra read the Law to the returned exiles, the Levites "gave the sense, so that the people understood the reading" (Neh 8:8, ESV). There was a sense to give. The Westminster Confession states the principle well:
The infallible rule of interpretation of Scripture is the Scripture itself: and therefore, when there is a question about the true and full sense of any Scripture (which is not manifold, but one), it must be searched and known by other places that speak more clearly.
(WCF 1.9)
The meaning is one; the applications are many. That distinction keeps what is true in reader-response criticism, the reader's real and personal engagement with the text, without surrendering the text to the reader. Nor is the meaning locked away from ordinary believers. The Confession goes on to say that what is necessary for salvation is so clearly set forth "that not only the learned, but the unlearned, in a due use of the ordinary means, may attain unto a sufficient understanding of them" (WCF 1.7).
In short, the reader who makes the Bible's meaning finds himself in the text. The reader who receives its meaning finds Christ, who, "beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, ... interpreted to them in all the Scriptures the things concerning himself" (Luke 24:27, ESV).
Reader-response criticism: common questions
What is reader-response criticism?
Reader-response criticism is a literary theory focusing on the reader's interpretation and response to a text. It holds that a text's meaning is not fixed and objective but depends on the reader's experiences, beliefs and cultural background, so the reader helps create the meaning.
Who developed reader-response criticism?
It took shape in the 1960s and 1970s. Louise Rosenblatt was an important forerunner (Literature as Exploration, 1938), and its key figures include Wolfgang Iser, Stanley Fish, Norman Holland, David Bleich, and Hans Robert Jauss.
What is the difference between reader-response criticism and New Criticism?
New Criticism locates meaning in the text itself and warns against judging a text by its effect on the reader, which Wimsatt and Beardsley called the "affective fallacy" (1949). Reader-response criticism locates meaning in the reader's experience of the text.
What are the types of reader-response criticism?
Lois Tyson identifies five: transactional (Rosenblatt, Iser), affective stylistics (Fish), subjective (Bleich), psychological (Holland), and social, built on Fish's "interpretive communities."
What is a reader-response lens?
Reading through a reader-response lens means paying attention to your own experience of a text: your expectations, reactions, and the gaps you fill in, and how your background shapes them.
What is an example of reader-response criticism?
Reading Philippians 4:13 ("I can do all things through him who strengthens me") as a promise of athletic victory treats the verse as meaning whatever it means to the reader. In context (Phil 4:11–12), Paul is speaking of contentment in plenty and in hunger.
What does reader-response criticism get right?
It rightly called modern methods such as form and source criticism into question, showing that they did not provide meaningful ways of interacting with the biblical text.
Is reader-response criticism a valid way to read the Bible?
No. Truth exists whether or not a reader knows it, and the Bible's message is clear and can be understood by any interpreter willing to understand its intended message. When the reader creates meaning, he tends to find himself in the text, and the life-saving message of Scripture is lost.
Jeremy Menicucci
Author
Jeremy Menicucci is a biblical counselor and apologist based in Albuquerque, NM. He specializes in nouthetic counseling and Christian apologetics, helping believers apply Scripture to everyday life.
View all posts by Jeremy Menicucci